You Asked, We Answered: Minimizing Athletic Risks Webinar Q&A

being there // Brian Gleason on Thursday September 21, 2017

In last week’s webinar, “Minimizing Athletic Risks: Protect Your Student Athletes and Your School,” Senior Risk Manager Brian Gleason dove into the ever-so-popular topics related to school-sponsored athletics and the risks associated with them. Below are questions – with answers – that were asked by our viewers during the webinar.

Q: Do helmets and other protective equipment prevent concussions?

A: Protective equipment does help as it will limit the impact; however, it often creates a sense of false security in athletes because they don’t feel the impact as much so they tend to hit harder and often end up with a more severe injury. So in the end, yes, protective equipment does limit the impact, but it will not always prevent a concussion from happening. The only true way to prevent concussions is to avoid impact altogether.

Q: How are concussions different in younger athletes?

A: Concussions in younger athletes can be harder to recognize because they don’t articulate as well what their symptoms are and might not communicate what they are feeling. Symptoms in younger athletes will also last longer than in older athletes, so they will need to be monitored longer. On the other side, older athletes will often try to “suck it up” and mislead the coach about their injury so that they don’t get taken out of the game.

Q: Are there specific concussion baseline tests that you would recommend? 

A: There are many programs out there at varying price points that provide a wide variety of baseline testing options. Three that I would recommend are:

MMC Concussion Tests 

Q: Our school doesn’t have the resources for all of the things you recommended for concussion safety. What should we focus on?

A: A high-priority item would be getting baseline testing done so that you have something to compare to if an athlete does sustain a head injury. Another high-priority item that will cost you nothing is to put together a clearly written procedure that spells out that medical professionals are the only people who can release an athlete back into competition after a head injury. In addition to that, be sure to indicate that any athlete suspected of a head injury should be immediately pulled from competition and not be released back to play until they have passed medical clearance.

Q: Where does liability begin and end for a school with regard to transportation?  For example, if practice doesn't begin until 5:30 p.m., and students take their own transportation home and then later to practice, is there any liability on the part of the school? ­What about driving themselves to an offsite practice facility?  

A:  In this type of situation, we would encourage you to consult with an attorney to clarify where liability lies. A general rule of thumb is that if you tell the student where the activity is and when they need to be there, but you do not arrange carpools or provide transportation, then the student is responsible and liable for their transportation. If you do arrange the carpool or provide transportation, then you are responsible and liable for the student. It is always a good idea to clearly outline transportation expectations prior to the season start at your parent meeting. In addition, if you will provide transportation but will give students the option to drive themselves, it is recommended that you have the student and parent sign a waiver stating that the student chooses to not take the provided transportation to help reduce liability.

Interested in learning more about this topic? A recording of the webinar is available here.

More questions? Let us know! Send your questions to and we will get you the answer you need. 

This material is for information only and is not intended to provide legal or professional advice. You are encouraged to consult with your own attorney or other expert consultants for a professional opinion specific to your situation. This information is only a general description of the available coverages and is not a contract. In an effort to keep your policy coverage affordable, the actual policy contains certain limitations and exclusion. Please refer to your insurance policy for the pertinent contract language and coverages. Some coverages and discounts are not available in all states. GuideOne welcomes all applications, without regard to religion, race, color, national origin, sex, handicap or familial status.

Brian Gleason

Brian Gleason

Brian Gleason is the Senior Risk Manager for Education at GuideOne Insurance, providing resources and consulting services to GuideOne clients in the education niche. Prior to his career at GuideOne, Brian spent twenty years in risk management for a Christian university in California. Brian has his MBA along with years of experience in insurance, enterprise risk management, occupational health and safety and emergency preparedness and response. 

A Look Ahead at 2018 Safety Trends & Risks for Churches

Tue, 01/16/2018 - 00:00
A lot can happen in a year, that’s for sure. While 2017 proved that things can change in an instant, there are trends and indicators that can prepare us for the most successful year yet. Here, the GuideOne risk management and loss control team forecasts risk management trends for churches in 2018. Let’s move forward together with these safety trends and tips in mind.

Details Matter: What You Need to Know About Liability Release Forms

Tue, 09/26/2017 - 08:00
Your organization likely sponsors a variety of exciting activities, including trips. Ensure full participation and minimal risk in all of your activities by having each participant sign a carefully worded assumption of risk and release of liability. If you fail to fully disclose the potential risks of your activity, you expose your organization to potential litigation.

Team Up With Your Local Law Enforcement

Tue, 08/29/2017 - 12:24
A regular police presence at or near your school, church and/or local neighborhood is a valuable crime-prevention strategy. In schools specifically, it can disrupt trouble spots that interfere with students traveling to and from school, prevent strangers from entering schools, identify students who are selling drugs or are under the influence of drugs, and more.

Youth Activities: The Good, The Bad and The Questionable

Tue, 08/01/2017 - 09:07

When school is out and summer activities are in, organizations are looking to fill each day with meaningful activities for youth in their programs. These activities can provide enriching experiences and vast learning opportunities for the participants. However, they can also present a new set of risks different from activities during the academic year.

How to Increase Building Security at Your School

Tue, 05/02/2017 - 08:55
“The best defense is a good offense.” Though this saying is typically used in sports scenarios, it rings especially true when it comes to school safety. The more emphasis you put on securing school grounds, the better off you’ll be at minimizing risk.

Experts suggest that you can enhance your school’s physical safety with the following strategies: